Back To Top
Should Babies Sleep with Their Parents?
A Research-Based Perspective on Co-Sleeping
There has long been debate around the question: should babies sleep with their parents? In Western cultures, it’s common to place infants in separate cribs or rooms, while in many parts of Asia and Africa, co-sleeping is the norm. But what does science say?
In this article, we explore the pros and cons of co-sleeping, backed by research from anthropologist James McKenna and others who have studied infant sleep and health for decades.
Co-Sleeping: A Natural Instinct?
According to Dr. James McKenna, a biological anthropologist at Pomona College, separate sleeping arrangements go against human evolutionary instincts. He observed that in most cultures, babies sleep next to their mothers, and even baby primates cling to their mothers through the night. This natural behavior suggests that co-sleeping may be safer and healthier than once believed.
SIDS and Co-Sleeping: Is There a Connection?
SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) refers to the sudden and unexplained death of a seemingly healthy baby. McKenna’s research indicates that co-sleeping—when done safely—may reduce the risk of SIDS.
When babies sleep close to their parents:
They are more alert to breathing rhythms
Their own breathing patterns stay more regular
Parents can quickly respond to distress
This physical proximity helps infants regulate their breathing and temperature, which can be life-saving.
Benefits of Co-Sleeping
Helps regulate the baby’s breathing and sleep cycles
Strengthens emotional bonding between baby and parents
Allows easier breastfeeding and soothing during the night
Provides a sense of security and reduces nighttime anxiety for the baby
Risks of Co-Sleeping
While co-sleeping can be beneficial, it does come with certain risks if not practiced carefully:
Increased chance of suffocation if parents are under the influence of alcohol, medication, or extreme fatigue
Risk of rolling over onto the baby on soft mattresses or with heavy bedding
Lack of personal space or disrupted sleep for parents
Unsafe if not using firm mattresses and proper sleep positions
Co-Sleeping in Modern Society
Modern parenting often emphasizes independence and autonomy from an early age. Many parents are advised to teach babies to “self-soothe” and sleep alone. However, McKenna argues that such practices prioritize adult convenience over the baby’s biological and emotional needs.
Cultural Differences
In countries like Japan, India, and many African nations, co-sleeping is deeply rooted in tradition. Interestingly, these regions report much lower rates of SIDS compared to Western countries, which may be linked to infant proximity and parental awareness during sleep.
What Does Research Say?
McKenna and his colleague Sarah Mosko gathered sleep data on mother-infant pairs. They found that when infants sleep beside their mothers, they wake more often but also experience more active sleep, which supports safer breathing patterns and reduces the likelihood of SIDS.
So, should babies sleep with their parents? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Co-sleeping can be safe and beneficial when done with awareness and proper precautions. If you choose this approach:
Use a firm mattress
Keep pillows and blankets away from the baby
Avoid co-sleeping when overly tired or under the influence
Always prioritize your baby’s safety over comfort or tradition
Ultimately, the best sleeping arrangement is the one that suits both the baby’s needs and the parents’ comfort—while always ensuring safety.
Inflect.in — Your daily dose of stories that inform, inspire, and ignite curiosity. Follow us for more!
